Yellow flag in Shepardizing indicates what?

Yellow flag in Shepardizing indicates what?

• A. Some negative history, but not reversed
• B. The case is no longer good law
• C. The case has been reversed on all points
• D. No negative history and remains good law

Answer: (A)

In Shepardizing, flags summarize how later history treats a case. A yellow flag signals caution: there is some negative history attached to the case—such as later decisions criticizing, distinguishing, or limiting it—but the holding itself hasn’t been reversed or undermined on the main points. So the case remains good law for its core proposition, albeit with caveats. That’s why the best match is the option describing some negative history, but not reversed. To contrast, a green flag would indicate no negative history and that the case is good law overall; a red flag would indicate it’s no longer good law or has been reversed on key points.

In Shepardizing, flags summarize how later history treats a case. A yellow flag signals caution: there is some negative history attached to the case—such as later decisions criticizing, distinguishing, or limiting it—but the holding itself hasn’t been reversed or undermined on the main points. So the case remains good law for its core proposition, albeit with caveats. That’s why the best match is the option describing some negative history, but not reversed. To contrast, a green flag would indicate no negative history and that the case is good law overall; a red flag would indicate it’s no longer good law or has been reversed on key points.